SHASTA COLLEGE LIBRARY
11555 Old Oregon Trail  *  PO Box 496006  *   Redding, CA 96049-6006
LIbrary Building Picture
| Home  Library Catalog Articles & Databases  Online eBooks  Search Internet  Local Links  Library Services  Help  |

Website Evaluation:
The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

      Books are often the resource of choice when you're after comprehensive coverage of an issue.  A quick glance at a book's title page and jacket will afford you a title, place and date of publication, author bio and credentials, and even some reviews.  Examine the preface, table of contents, index, and bibliography and you begin to gauge the volume's strengths, shortcomings, and bias.  But many important topics, especially those of a local nature, don't have the large readership that economically justifies publication of an entire book.  Other stories are too current to be well represented by the mainstream press (there's a lag of at least nine months between a book's completion and its publication). For these stories, the Internet, where publishing is inexpensive, instantaneous, and simple, is heaven sent.  But when anyone can publish anything, finding the right site among the billions and evaluating the information contained in that site requires a healthy measure of skepticism.
    This task is further complicated because the Internet is a medium where the author also serves as editor and publisher. The helpful publication information taken for granted in print books and magazines is often hidden or missing from webpages.  Determining bias and reliability requires some detective work and much critical thinking.  The Shasta College librarians recommend that each website visited be scrutinized for:

Try this 5 point technique on at least one website from each of the four categories listed below.  Evaluation strategies are outlined in the handout, Consider the Source. Visit these pages to learn more about critical evaluation of webpages:


| Home  Library Catalog Articles & Databases  Online eBooks  Search Internet  Local Links  Library Services  Help  |

URL: http://library.shastacollege.edu/webevaluation.html
  Electronic Mail: webmaster@library.shastacollege.edu
      Updated: 11/17/04