SHASTA
COLLEGE LIBRARY
L.I.F.E.
Learning Community
Course: Learning Integrated with
the Future Environment
Instructors: Turner/Gorden/Waite
Evaluating
Information: Website vs. Printed
Books are the resource of choice when
you're after comprehensive coverage of an issue. A quick glance at
a book's title page and jacket will afford you a title, place and date
of publication, author bio and credentials, and even some reviews.
Examine the preface, table of contents, index, and bibliography and you
begin to gauge the volume's strengths, shortcomings, and bias. But
many important topics, especially those of a local nature, don't have the
large readership that economically justifies publication of an entire book.
Other stories are too current to be well represented by the mainstream
press (there's a lag of at least nine months between a book's completion
and its publication). For these stories, the Web, where publishing is inexpensive,
instantaneous, and simple, is heaven sent. But when anyone can publish
anything, finding the right site among the billions and evaluating the
information contained in that site requires a healthy measure of skepticism.
Clicking to a webpage from a search engine is like hopping off a
plane in a foreign land without a tour guide or maps. How do you
orient yourself when the documentation is sketchy? The helpful
publication information taken for granted in print books and magazines
is often hidden or missing from webpages in this territory where the author
also serves as editor and publisher. Determining bias and reliability
requires some detective work and much critical thinking. Below are a few
tutorials and guides to website selection and evaluation.
Locating
Information: Books/Videotapes/Maps
-
To locate materials that the Library owns,
search the Library's online WEBCATalog.
Favorite Reference Books (for use
in library only) include:
Atlases
California. Resources Agency. Sacramento
River Environmental Atlas
[Atlas G1527.S2 O4 C3 1978]
Hornbeck, David. California Patterns
: A Geographical and Historical Atlas
[Atlas G1525 .H6 1983]
Kahrl, William L. The California Water
Atlas [Atlas G1526.C3 C3 1979]
Kreissman, Bern. California, An Environmental
Atlas & Guide [Atlas QH541.262.C2 K54 1991]
Mason, Robert J. Atlas of United States
Environmental Issues [Atlas G1201.G3 M3 1990]
Dictionaries and Encyclopedias
Allaby, Michael. A dictionary of the
environment [Reference QH540.4 .A44 ]
Bisio, Attilio. Encyclopedia of energy
technology and the environment [Reference TJ163.235 .E53 1995
]
Bisio, Attilio. The Wiley encyclopedia
of energy and the environment [Reference TJ163.235 .W55 1997]
Douglas, Ian. Companion encyclopedia
of geography : the environment and humankind
[Reference G116 .C645 1996 ]
Yearbooks
Worldwatch Institute. State of the
world : a Worldwatch Institute report on progress toward a sustainable
society
[Reference HC59 .S734 2001]
Locating
Information: Articles
The Library has subscriptions to
several excellent online databases to help you locate magazine and newspaper
articles:
-
Magazines and Periodicals (EBSCOhost)
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access*
How To Use This Resource HTML
| PDF§
What's Hot: Simple to search, retrieve,
print or email; Broad coverage of current events and human interest topics;
Be sure to check out the Search Web Links on the results page.
What's Not:Limited coverage of
humanities, history, and local issues; photos and graphics omitted.
-
National Newspapers (ProQuest)
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access*
How To Use This Resource HTML
| PDF§
What's Hot: Simple to print or
email; Broad coverage of current events topics; Recently added archival
files.
What's Not:Somewhat challenging
to search, user must take care in selection of collection and date range.
-
General Reference Center Gold (Infotrac)
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access*
What's Hot: Simple to search, print
or email; Broad coverage of current events topics; Best graphics of all
the online research databases.
What's Not: Limited coverage of
humanities, history, and local issues.
-
Sacramento Bee
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access*
What's Hot: Simple to search, print
or email; Good for stories of local (Northern California) interest.
What's Not:Recent copyright battles
have reduced coverage to the past two years only. (It's hoped that these
copyright and coverage woes are temporary).
-
CQ Researcher
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access*
What's Hot: Simple to search and
print or email. Presents concise, well balanced reports on contemporary,
controversial issues of national importance. Each article contains a chronology,
footnotes, annotated bibliography, and web links for continued research.
A great place to start.
What's Not: Limited number of issues
covered. Slow to load. Emailing complete issues often fails
(although sections can be emailed).
-
SIRS Knowledge Source
On Campus
Access
Off
Campus Access*
About
the Database
What's Hot: Simple to search, print
or email; Includes many reports from U.S. Government offices; Broad coverage
of current events topics
What's Not:Limited coverage of
humanities, history, and local issues.
-
Counting California
On
Campus Access
Off
Campus Access
What's Hot: Provides access to
statistical data compiled by federal, state, and local agencies; Aims for
historical as well as contemporary data.
Other useful databases are available
on the Library's Articles
& Databases web page.
*A Library Card is required to access
this resource from off campus. For information about acquiring a Library
Card see "How do I get a Library Card?" on the Library's Frequently
Asked Questions web page.
§To read PDF files you must
install the Adobe® Acrobat® Reader. Information about this application,
which is available for free, is available on the Library's
Software
Tools web page.
Locating
Information: Internet Resources
Remember to be careful when choosing
Internet resources for your research as some web sites contain unreliable
information. To help you determine
if the information you found on the Internet is good information, consult
a web site
evaluation tool such as Consider
the Source: Evaluating Research Tools or Thinking
Critically about World Wide Web Resources or one of the other Internet
guides listed on the bottom of the Library's Internet
Search Engines web page.
One way to search with confidence
is to use a classified list, that is, a list of sites that have been evaluated,
selected, and indexed by subject area. Philip Roche, the Shasta College
Library webmaster, maintains Internet
Reference a list of sites selected with Shasta College students
in mind. Librarians' Index to the Internet
is an annotated directory to nearly 10,000 Internet Web sites. These
sites have been selected and reviewed by librarians (if you can't trust
a librarian, who can you trust?). LII is indexed by subject and searchable
by both subject and keyword. Because it's a small collection, remember
to search broadly (water might prove more successful than
Klamath Basin Crisis).
Some excellent online sources for
LIFE: Learning Integrated with the Future Environment include:
INFOMINE--
http://infomine.ucr.edu/
A Virtual Library created by librarians
at the University of California campuses.
For class project research:
Select the area “Biological, Agricultural
& Medical Sciences” then search the alphabetic listings for “Agriculture”
and “Environment” for many useful links. U.C. Davis
Information
Center for the Environment (ICE)--http://ice.ucdavis.edu
Links to current environmental projects
such as “California Rivers Assessment”
“A cooperative effort of environmental
scientists at U.C. Davis and …over 30 other organizations interested in
environmental protection.”
Agricultural
Issues Center--http://aic.ucdavis.edu/
Links to an overview of the Center’s
activities, publications, and more.
U.C.
Davis Related Links--http://aic.ucdavis.edu/links/default.html
Links to government agencies and
research programs in environmental resources and agriculture.
Additional
Useful Web Links
Shasta
College Library Information
If you need to come to the Library to
conduct some or all of your research, you can see a listing of open hours
for the Fall 2001 Semester on the Library's Library
Hours web page.
If you would like to contact a librarian
for assistance during hours when the Library is not open, please leave
a phone message at (530) 225-4975 or send email to webmaster@library.shastacollege.edu.
All of the resources listed on this
page (and more) are available via the Shasta
College Library web site 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Shasta College
Library - L.I.F.E. Learning Community
URL: http://library.shastacollege.edu/life.htm
This page last updated:
03/28/02
Electronic Mail: webmaster@library.shastacollege.edu
