| |
Print and Library Databases
|
Internet (World Wide Web)
|
|
Authority
|
-
Is the author's name given? What experience,
education, or credentials does the author have relevant to the topic?
-
Is the publisher well known or a government
agency?
|
-
Anyone can publish anything on the Web.
-
The domain name indicates the sponsor
of a site:
-
professional associations (.org)
-
government (.gov)
-
educational institution (.edu)
-
commercial business (.com)
-
network (often commercial) (.net)
-
Is the name of a contact person, webmaster,or
organization given?
|
|
Accuracy
|
-
Are sources of information clearly stated?
-
Is the author affiliated with a special
interest group?
|
-
Are sources of data given and
are they reliable?
-
Links to other web sites must also be
checked for accuracy.
|
|
Objectivity
|
-
Does the author present varied
aspects of an issue or is he promoting a certain opinion?
-
What sources are cited for the information
given as facts?
|
-
Web pages exist for many different purposes:
to advertise an idea or product, promote an individual's views, or to entertain.
-
Anybody can create a web page.
|
|
Timeliness
|
-
For some research the most current
information is needed. Other research requires that a topic be followed
through time using sources from years ago.
-
Check publication date of the book in
hand. Also review the publication dates of the works cited as references.
|
-
A web page should give the date
created or most recently updated.
-
Web pages are often short lived. What
you see one week may be revised or disappear the following week. Keep a
record of the date you visit a site and include that date when you cite
your sources.
|
|
Coverage
|
-
Does the information thoroughly cover
the topic chosen?
-
Does it add new information or merely
repeat points already found?
|
-
Is the information at a level appropriate
to your needs? Is it too simple, technical, or general for your purposes?
|
